MI2N
Music Industry News Network
TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 9TH
Advanced Search
Tag It Advertising Network
Subscribe to Mi2N's Free Newsletters B2N (business) i2N (indie)
HOME | FREE NEWS SUBMISSION | PR DISTRIBUTION | PR COPYWRITING | GIFT CERTIFICATES | RSS FEEDS | TESTIMONIALS | CONTACT

Sections: Band | Business | Career | Events | Label | Music Releases | Radio | Tech | Video | Web Events
Genres: Country/Folk | Dance/Electronica | Jazz/Blues | Latin | Rock | Urban | World
International: Asia | Canada | Europe

Advertise | Artist Development | Submit Video | MusicDish e-Journal | MusicDish Network | Urban Music News Network
Mi2N - Music Industry News Network
Business News (more headlines) 06-16-2000

Rosen House Testimony On Online Music Opportunities

Bookmark and Share
My name is Hilary Rosen, and I am the President of the Recording Industry Association of America, Inc. ("RIAA"). I would like to thank Chairman Coble, Representative Berman and the other members of this Subcommittee for holding this hearing today. As you know, RIAA member labels are responsible for producing and distributing over 90 percent of the legitimate sound recordings sold in the United States. This Subcommittee has always been in the forefront of these cutting edge Internet issues and I commend you for continuing your work with this hearing today. There is no longer any doubt that the Internet is at the center of a revolution in the way consumers enjoy copyrighted works. We think this is a great thing. The Internet opens up so many opportunities for the public's enjoyment of music that were never imagined before. Even just a few years ago, the Internet was simply a marketing and promotional tool for the music industry. The business models have changed, are continuing to change, and businesses have been both proactive and reactive regarding the constantly evolving technology. With technologies like the streaming of music over the Internet and the ability to download songs directly onto a computer, consumers have access to more copyrighted works each day, and record companies are working with webcasters and other Internet businesses to facilitate consumers' access to these works in a legal and equitable way. The music community's challenges on the Internet have been in the news lately. There is a significant piracy issue and we are testing areas of the copyright law in some cutting edge ways. While I would be happy to respond to any specific questions about the piracy issue, my purpose today is to inform the Subcommittee about all of the positive opportunities being created by the Internet for consumers, technology entrepreneurs and the music community alike. For music, the Internet is particularly important. Since the early days of the record business, artists and record companies could essentially make a return o their investment only one way - by selling a packaged recording. This was a historic anomaly created by the lack of a public performance in sound recordings. In 1995, after consideration for over 20 years, Congress determined that a right of public performance would benefit consumers, artists and record companies, and created the Digital Performance Right In Sound Recordings Act. The thinking was that the rules of the road had been written for analog, but new digital distribution models would open up so new many avenues that sound recording copyright owners should be encouraged to take risks in the new digital arena. What an act of foresight by this Committee and the Congress! For it was exactly that legislation that now allows us to give the consumer new and varied choices in their music consumption. Instead of only selling a full album of packaged goods, artists and record companies are looking at subscription services, singles and compilation downloads, artist packages, on-line jukeboxes and so many more. Prices, in my view, will be cheaper for the consumer because consumers will get exactly what they want, and the opportunities for the industry and artist will grow as volume increases. Webcasting is a perfect example of a new consumer service made possible by the new public performance right. As you may already know, with webcasting, or "Internet radio," a user can visit a webcaster's site, click on a button and receive a stream of music through his or her PC. In general, webcasters do not charge the user any fee to receive the music, and the user has a huge amount of genres and stations to choose from that far exceed what is currently available on over-the-air analog radio. In addition, some radio stations are transmitting their own stations over the Internet, therefore expanding their reach and service to listeners and advertisers. Other webcasters serve as aggregators and retransmit the signal of many over-the-air broadcast stations.

The DPRA and the DMCA The revolution of the Internet and the proliferation of webcasters have raised a large number of questions, many of which are relevant to this hearing: whether and how copyright law should be changed to accommodate this new reality. When the 1995 Act was passed, we did not anticipate the volume of licensing issues the recording industry would face. Nor did we anticipate the rapid growth of this new business now called "webcasting." Because so many webcasters were faced with the need to have easy access to thousands of songs requiring complex licensing mechanisms, new rules were created and implemented in the Digital Millenium Copyright Act ("DMCA"). The DMCA thus provided for efficient licensing mechanisms for webcasters and others. While we, like other copyright interests, as well as the US Government, have historically been opposed to compulsory licensing, we thought that the blanket license model made sense in this unique environment for this specific purpose. We think the process set up by Congress and currently in place is a good one. The statutory license in the DMCA has worked to help all sides. It allows us to negotiate rates with webcasters on both an individual and industry-wide basis, and if an industry-wide agreement is not reached an arbitration panel will decide rates for qualifying webcasters based on rates already in the marketplace rates. We look forward to participating in this new process and watching it develop.

Building the New Marketplace RIAA strongly believes the steps Congress has taken in the past five years are essential to the future of recorded music, and that the structure Congress has established is the right one. We are grateful to you, Chairman Coble, and to this Subcommittee, for your leadership in this regard. The goal of Congress, the RIAA on behalf of its members, webcasters, and others should be to build a legitimate marketplace for the music industry, and the current process is working to accomplish such goals. For example, we have been successfully negotiating licenses with webcasters for more than a year. The process is not easy because many webcasters have a steep learning curve before understanding the ground rules. But marketplace negotiations afford the parties the opportunity to create flexible and mutually beneficial agreements. We try to tailor the licenses to meet the needs of each individual company. Given the variety of business models employed by creative entrepreneurs, we realize this is not a one-size-fits-all business and our ability to negotiate with different entities in different ways works to the benefit of everyone. Of course, the royalties flowing from these licenses must be distributed. In addition, the Copyright Office has appointed us to collect and distribute certain other royalties. So we've been hard at work to set up a means to get the money to those who deserve it, the creators of the recordings. Royalties will be distributed based on reported performance information and a board made up of a cross section of the industry will oversee the process. We look forward to providing this service to all copyright owners, including the hundreds of independent record labels that have signed up with us. More important than what RIAA is doing, individual record companies and artists have also worked with a variety of new technology companies to develop fresh and exciting ways for consumers to enjoy copyrighted sound recordings. They are planning to work with webcasters to create even more personalized programming - artist specific channels or customized radio with a high degree of consumer interaction. They are redefining business models and forming unprecedented business relationships to develop legitimate ways to access copyrighted music online. All of the major labels have announced plans to start selling music as digital downloads this summer. EMI is working with Preview Systems and Supertracks; BMG with IBM, InterTrust and Microsoft; Warner with Sony's ATRAC3; Universal with Magex; and Sony with music distributor Alliance Entertainment's 35 retail accounts, including Peaches and National Record Mart. Major independent label Zomba will also sell downloads this summer, and independent label TVT will sell their music through MusicMaker.com's custom compilation CD service. With regard to webcasting and streaming, BMG has licensed almost all of its sound recordings to MusicBank.com, a service that allows users to store, manage, and listen to music over the Internet. Sony and Universal have announced plans to develop a subscription music service where users pay a monthly fee to access their sound recordings. The value of reaching fans has not been lost on Warner Music Group, along with other labels, who have invested in consumer music sites ArtistDirect.com (a fan community and artist merchandising site) and Listen.com (a directory for legitimate downloads and streams). On the artist front, Todd Rundgren has re-launched his music subscription service, where fans pay a monthly or annual fee to access his new music, to include other artists wanting to do the same. Chuck D runs the rap and hip-hop Web site Rapstation.com, which gives exposure to artists as well as digital music issues. And many more artists have used the Internet on their own and with fan community Web sites like Fanscape.com to build strong relationships with their fans, sell merchandise, and promote upcoming tours and releases.

The Challenges Ahead But we still have work to do. Although marketplace negotiations have worked with many webcasters, industry-wide agreement has not yet been produced. Thus, it is likely that an arbitration panel will determine the rates for the other webcasters. One issue that has arisen in the course of negotiations is whether radio broadcast stations that webcast their local over-the-air AM/FM signal to Internet users throughout the world should be granted special treatment among webcasters. While there is no question that over-the-air transmissions of broadcast stations are exempt from the digital performance right in sound recordings, RIAA believes the law is just as clear that Internet streaming of that signal is subject to the digital performance right. In fact, Congress made clear that third parties such as Yahoo! Broadcast that retransmit over-the-air signals on the Internet are covered, so it would make no sense to allow the identical streaming to be exempt merely because a broadcast station performed the webcasting itself. A different result would give broadcasters a competitive advantage in an entirely new medium merely because they hold an FCC license that has no application to the Internet. RIAA has asked the Copyright Office to decide this issue. The Digital Media Association ("DiMA") has also filed a petition with the Copyright Office asking for a ruling concerning certain types of webcasting services that allow listeners to personalize the music they receive. DiMA claims that such services qualify for the statutory license as noninteractive services. In RIAA's view, these services fall squarely within the definition of "interactive service" as revised in the DMCA, and thus they require individually negotiated licenses from the copyright owners. In any event, RIAA believes that the personalization issue is highly fact-specific and inappropriate for rulemaking. As was discussed by the first panel of witnesses, it is very rare for Congress to grant compulsory licenses. Congress has not done so for webcasters that run a personalized service, and it should allow record companies to negotiate with these entities for individual licenses in the marketplace.

Conclusion In sum, the ongoing negotiations are complex and challenging due to the many business models employed by webcasters and the lack of a single representative for all entities. But the marketplace is working. The system is working. And we believe that the current course of action is the correct one. Thank you again for the opportunity to appear today. I hope this background has been helpful, and I would be pleased to answer any questions you might have.

Bookmark and Share

back | top



MusicDish Advertising Network

Mi2N Music PR


MyMusicSuccess Teams Up With Top US Producer Mike Rizzo To Break Pop Crossover Artists Into The Billboard Charts


Rivmixx.com Announce Industry Bloggers: John Robb, Ty, Kutski, And The Music Consultants Join The Rivmixx Revolution


SPIDER ROCKETS To Join POP EVIL On Midwest Tour


Kluger: Debut Album & Some Raw Heartache


Last Chance, The New Single Of Robert Lauri


Dolly Trolly CD Release At The Bitter End


Professor Louie & The Crowmatix - New Release

Mi2N's Music PR distribution service guarantees online exposure for your press release. Choose from seven (7) different packages.

Follow/Friend Mi2N:
MusicDish Network Advertising

News Headlines
Mi2N EDITOR'S PICKS
» SABAM Vs Tiscali - The Case Is Being Referred To The European Court Of Justice Of Luxemburg
» METAlliance Certifies Millennia HV-3R Mic Pre
» Two Ton Anvil Signs With Dark Star Records
» Film Industry Disappointed By Federal Court Ruling On Online Copyright Infringement
» Media Institute Opposes RIAA Performance Tax
» Ricardo B. Salinas Pliego Receives 'Medalla Mozart 2010'
» David Knight Presents MTEC
» Comedy At Gonzalez Y Gonzalez Returns On Wednesday, February 24th With Erik Rivera, Peaches Rodriguez, Andrew Kennedy And Many More...
» The Midnight Kites Release Debut Album
» The Official Jamie Lynn Noon App - A Moment To Break


Get your music news covered...
Have your press release written
by the pros at Mi2N

Articles
MUSICDISH E-JOURNAL
» The New Miles Davis Tribute Headphones By Monster Cable At NAMM
» Composing Music For Movies - The New Way
» Doing Business At MIDEM 2010
» Music Gets Back To Business
» HMV X Tube - Music In Sessions
» MusicDish*China 'Eye On China': Red Orchestra - Solo
» Global Survey Reveals Music Trends Rocking Fans Across The World
» MusicDish*China Sounds Live At MIDEM
» Riding The Korean Wave In Asia
» MusicDish*China Sounds At MIDEM 2010
» How Compulsory License For Internet Might STILL Help Music Industry Woes
» Getting Too Into Indie Rock In 2010

Order an Mi2N Music PR package for an opportunity to submit a song for FREE to one of the hundreds of industry opportunities available through Music Xray


Mi2N - Music Industry News Network
HOME | FREE NEWS SUBMISSION | PR DISTRIBUTION | PR COPYWRITING | GIFT CERTIFICATES | RSS FEEDS | TESTIMONIALS | CONTACT

Sections: Band | Business | Career | Events | Label | Music Releases | Radio | Tech | Video | Web Events
Genres: Country/Folk | Dance/Electronica | Jazz/Blues | Latin | Rock | Urban | World
International: Asia | Canada | Europe

Advertise | Artist Development | Submit Video | MusicDish e-Journal | MusicDish Network | Urban Music News Network
Copyright © 1997-2010 MusicDish LLC, all rights reserved. Text, graphics, and HTML code are protected by US and International Copyright Laws, and may not be copied, reprinted, published, translated, hosted, or otherwise distributed by any means without explicit permission.